Claim and evidence
The new icon with the smiling witch smashed the previous two, with a 9.1% conversion lift.MyTona (Seekers Notes) · gameanalytics.com · 2017-09-11
Primary
The company or founder describes the tactic and its result themselves: own blog, talk, filing.
The smiling-witch icon beat both earlier icons with a 9.1% conversion lift (vendor-reported).
Working · 2026-11 Apple documentation, copyright 2026
What the numbers show
conversion lift for the smiling-witch icon in MyTona's icon tests (vendor-reported, third-party testing)
gameanalytics.comWhy it works
Treatments are shown to randomly selected visitors so you can see which assets convert best.
How to run it
- Pick one asset to vary
- Create up to three treatments
- Run the test
- Apply the winner
Before / after
Generalised wireframe of the pattern, not a copy of any company's screen.
Ways to run it
Design options to test, not promised results.
- Option AIcon series
Test icon concepts one after another and keep the winner as the new baseline, as MyTona did.
- Option BScreenshot story
Hold the icon fixed and test which screenshot order explains the app best.
- Option CApp preview video
Test a page with an app preview against one with screenshots only.
Dated examples
- —
MyTona (Seekers Notes)
Ran a series of store icon A/B tests comparing a man in a hat, a pumpkin head and a smiling witch (third-party store testing, before Apple's native tool).
The smiling-witch icon beat both earlier icons with a 9.1% conversion lift (vendor-reported).
“The new icon with the smiling witch smashed the previous two, with a 9.1% conversion lift.”
✓ quote checked word-for-word on the pagegameanalytics.com · 2017-09-11
Does it still work?
Apple documentation, copyright 2026 source
Risks
- Needs enough traffic
- Page does not say organic-only
Sources
- developer.apple.com
“A test can include up to three treatments with alternate app icons, screenshots, and app previews.”
✓ quote checked word-for-word on the page - developer.apple.com
“Conversion lift: Understand the estimated relative improvement of each treatment compared to your baseline, helping you quantify the impact of specific creative changes.”
✓ quote checked word-for-word on the page
Change log
- 2026-11-20 — merged: pass2-enrich.jsonl:18 (apple-product-page-optimization-tests); acq-search.jsonl:45 (apple-product-page-optimization-tests)
- 2026-11-20 — harvest v0.1 (pass2-enrich, acq-search)