Working · 2026-11PrimaryActivationAnalytics

Run the "very disappointed" PMF survey

Ask users how they would feel if they could no longer use the product and track the share who answer "very disappointed".

Claim and evidence

The claimWithin just three quarters of our work to improve the product, the score nearly doubled to 58%.

Superhuman · review.firstround.com · 2018-11-12

What the numbers show

40%

share of very disappointed users that Sean Ellis found to mark product-market fit

review.firstround.com
58%

Superhuman's score after three quarters of product work (company account)

review.firstround.com

Why it works

Diagram, not data
Share answering very disappointedWeak fitEllis's lineStrong fitRead comments for what to fix
Share answering very disappointedWeak fitEllis's lineStrong fitRead comments for what to fix

Sean Ellis found 40% as the line; Superhuman used it as a tracked score. It diagnoses whether activation work is chasing a product that people value.

How to run it

  1. Survey users who have experienced the core product
  2. Calculate the share who answer "very disappointed"
  3. Track the score each quarter
  4. Read the open comments for what to fix

Before / after

Before
How satisfied are you with Product?
Send
Broad satisfaction question
After
How would you feel if you could no longer use Product?
Very disappointed
Somewhat disappointed
Not disappointed
What is the main benefit you get?
Send
One question about losing the product

Generalised wireframe of the pattern, not a copy of any company's screen.

Ways to run it

Design options to test, not promised results.

  1. Option AQuarterly tracked score

    Run the same question every quarter and track the trend, as Superhuman did.

  2. Option BOnly experienced users

    Survey people who have used the core product, so the answer reflects real use.

  3. Option CComments as roadmap input

    Read the open answers for the main benefit and the main blocker, and plan work from them.

Timeline

  1. 12018 first documented: Rahul Vohra, First Round Review (attributing Sean Ellis)
  2. 22018 Superhuman — Started at 22% "very disappointed"; segmenting raised it to 33% and three quarters of work to 58%.
  3. 32026-11 status checked: Working

Dated examples

  1. 2018

    Superhuman

    Started at 22% "very disappointed"; segmenting raised it to 33% and three quarters of work to 58%.

    Score nearly doubled to 58%.

    “Within just three quarters of our work to improve the product, the score nearly doubled to 58%.”
    ✓ quote checked word-for-word on the page

    review.firstround.com · 2018-11-12

Does it still work?

Workingas of 2026-11

Founder's own account, Nov 2018; 40% rule attributed to Sean Ellis.

Risks

  • Needs about 40 respondents to be directionally useful
  • Do not treat 40% as a universal law

Sources

  1. review.firstround.com · First Round Review · Rahul Vohra · 2018-11-12
    “Ellis found that the magic number was 40%.”
    ✓ quote checked word-for-word on the page

Change log

  • 2026-11-20 — harvest v0.1 (activation)