Claim and evidence
Prioritise tests by answering yes/no questions about each idea, so evidence rather than opinion drives the order.
No dated example yet. Treat this tactic as a hypothesis.
Primary
The company or founder describes the tactic and its result themselves: own blog, talk, filing.
Working · 2026-11 Maintained by CXL (page updated 2026-11-06); a counterweight to subjective ICE and PIE.
What the numbers show
No published number for this tactic has passed our word-for-word check yet, so there is no chart.
Why it works
Binary questions leave no room for equivocation, and asking people to bring data reduces subjective scoring. The checklist can be adapted to a company's own risks.
How to run it
- Write yes/no criteria (visible above the fold, backed by research, easy to build)
- Answer each criterion for every idea
- Sum the yes answers
- Rank and run the top ideas
- Adapt the criteria to your business
Ways to run it
Design options to test, not promised results.
- Option AStandard checklist
Use criteria such as visible without scrolling, backed by research and easy to build.
- Option BWeighted yes answers
Give extra weight to the criteria that matter most for your business.
- Option CBring-the-data rule
Accept a yes on research-backed questions only when someone attaches the evidence.
Timeline
- 12016 first documented: Peep Laja, CXL
- 22026-11 status checked: Working
Dated examples
No dated example yet. Treat this tactic as a hypothesis.
Does it still work?
Maintained by CXL (page updated 2026-11-06); a counterweight to subjective ICE and PIE. source
Risks
- More up-front work than ICE
- Criteria tuned for CRO may not fit product experiments
Sources
- cxl.com
“We wanted something that eliminated equivocation – you have to make a yes or no, binary decision, when ranking items.”
✓ quote checked word-for-word on the page
Change log
- 2026-11-20 — harvest v0.1 (ops-ai)