Saturating · 2022-08SecondaryReferralProduct

Taper the cash referral bonus as growth matures

Start with a rich cash bonus to ignite growth, then step it down and add verification as the network gains momentum.

Claim and evidence

The claim7 to 10% daily growth and 100 million users

PayPal · referralcandy.com · 2022-08-19

What the numbers show

7–10%

daily growth cited from Peter Thiel's notes (PayPal, via ReferralCandy)

referralcandy.com

Why it works

Diagram, not data
Network momentumLaunch: rich cash bonusMomentum: smaller bonusOrganic growth takes overSunset the bonus
Network momentumLaunch: rich cash bonusMomentum: smaller bonusOrganic growth takes overSunset the bonus

Early large payouts buy attention at launch; later network size and habit carry growth at lower cost.

How to run it

  1. Launch with a rich bonus
  2. Track cost per new user
  3. Reduce bonus in steps
  4. Add verification to curb abuse
  5. Sunset when organic takes over

Ways to run it

Design options to test, not promised results.

  1. Option AStep-down schedule

    Cut the bonus in planned steps as cost per new user is tracked, as PayPal did.

  2. Option BVerification gate

    Pay only after the new account passes checks such as a confirmed card or bank link, to curb abuse.

  3. Option CSunset trigger

    Agree in advance which signal, such as the share of organic signups, ends the program.

Timeline

  1. 12000 first documented: PayPal (secondary account, 2022)
  2. 22000 PayPal — Bonus cut from $20 to $10 to $5; Musk estimated total spend of $60-70 million.
  3. 32022-08 status checked: Saturating

Dated examples

  1. 2000

    PayPal

    Bonus cut from $20 to $10 to $5; Musk estimated total spend of $60-70 million.

    Thiel notes cite 7 to 10 percent daily growth.

    “7 to 10% daily growth and 100 million users”
    ✓ quote checked word-for-word on the page

    referralcandy.com · 2022-08-19

Does it still work?

Saturatingas of 2022-08

Accounts conflict on starting amounts; written by a third party from interviews and notes. source

Risks

  • Sources disagree on amounts
  • High cost per user

Sources

  1. referralcandy.com · ReferralCandy blog · Visakan Veerasamy · 2022-08-19
    “7 to 10% daily growth and 100 million users”
    ✓ quote checked word-for-word on the page

Change log

  • 2026-11-20 — harvest v0.1 (referral-loops)