Working · 2013-07PrimaryAcquisitionMarketplaces

Seed the hard side of a marketplace by hand

Recruit early supply manually (door to door, photos, onboarding by founders) because marketplaces do not start themselves.

Claim and evidence

The claimMarketplaces are so hard to get rolling that you should expect to take heroic measures at first.

Airbnb · paulgraham.com · 2013-07

What the numbers show

No published number for this tactic has passed our word-for-word check yet, so there is no chart.

Why it works

Diagram, not data
Recruit supply byhandBetter listingsBuyers find optionsMore supply wantsin
Recruitsupply byhandBetterlistingsBuyers findoptionsMore supplywants in

Without supply there is nothing to attract demand; manual effort at the start substitutes for network effects not yet present.

How to run it

  1. Identify the hard side
  2. Recruit by hand in one dense area
  3. Improve each listing personally
  4. Scale only after liquidity appears

Ways to run it

Design options to test, not promised results.

  1. Option ADoor to door in one city

    Founders recruit suppliers in one dense area and improve each listing, as Airbnb did in New York.

  2. Option BDo the work for them

    Create or polish listings on behalf of early suppliers so the bar to join is low.

  3. Option CExpand after liquidity

    Move to a new area only once buyers reliably find what they need in the first.

Dated examples

  1. —

    Airbnb

    Founders went door to door in New York recruiting hosts and improving listings.

    “Marketplaces are so hard to get rolling that you should expect to take heroic measures at first.”
    ✓ quote checked word-for-word on the page

    paulgraham.com · 2013-07

Does it still work?

Workingas of 2013-07

Essay is 2013 and still the standard reference. source

Risks

  • Does not scale by design
  • Survivorship bias

Sources

  1. paulgraham.com · paulgraham.com · Paul Graham · 2013-07
    “Marketplaces are so hard to get rolling that you should expect to take heroic measures at first.”
    ✓ quote checked word-for-word on the page

Change log

  • 2026-11-20 — harvest v0.1 (referral-loops)