Claim and evidence
Instantly's 2026 data shows 58% of replies arrive from the first email in a sequence.Instantly via lemlist · lemlist.com · 2026-08-17
Vendor claim
A tool vendor reports numbers about its own customers or product. Useful, but not independent.
58% of replies from first email.
Working · 2026-11 Guidance from tool vendor; the FAQ suggests 4-6 follow-ups, body 5-7.
What the numbers show
of replies arrive from the first email in a sequence (Instantly data cited by lemlist, vendor data)
lemlist.comWhy it works
Most replies come from the first email; later touches still add some, but returns fall.
How to run it
- Plan 5-7 touches
- Space 2-4 days
- Stop when no new value
- Review reply decay
Ways to run it
Design options to test, not promised results.
- Option AStrong first email
Put most effort into the first message, since it draws most replies.
- Option BShort value sequence
Run a handful of touches a few days apart, each with something new.
- Option CDecay review
Check where replies stop and cut steps that add nothing.
Dated examples
- 2026
Instantly via lemlist
Reports first email yields most replies.
58% of replies from first email.
“Instantly's 2026 data shows 58% of replies arrive from the first email in a sequence.”
✓ quote checked word-for-word on the pagelemlist.com · 2026-08-17
Does it still work?
Guidance from tool vendor; the FAQ suggests 4-6 follow-ups, body 5-7. source
Risks
- Inconsistent guidance
- Spam complaints if daily
Sources
- lemlist.com
“Space follow-ups two to four days apart.”
✓ quote checked word-for-word on the page
Change log
- 2026-11-20 — fact-check: paraphrase replaced with page text (https://lemlist.com/blog/cold-email-benchmarks/)
- 2026-11-20 — harvest v0.1 (acq-outbound)