Claim and evidence
requires 10 purchases, but with two awarded upon enrollmentCar wash loyalty card experiment · knowledge.wharton.upenn.edu · 2006-09-06
Secondary
A reputable third party analysed it (Lenny's Newsletter, First Round Review, Reforge, an Ahrefs study).
Higher completion for the pre-stamped card (Wharton write-up).
Working · 2026-11 Marketing study from 2006 (not an onboarding test); onboarding use is by analogy.
What the numbers show
No published number for this tactic has passed our word-for-word check yet, so there is no chart.
Why it works
People persist more when they already feel some progress; the effect is shown in a loyalty-card field test.
How to run it
- Pick the checklist or profile bar
- Pre-complete a first step
- Explain why
- Compare completion with an empty start
Before / after
Generalised wireframe of the pattern, not a copy of any company's screen.
Ways to run it
Design options to test, not promised results.
- Option APre-completed first item
Count an action the user already did, such as creating the account, as the first checklist step.
- Option BProfile bar head start
Start a profile completeness bar partly full from data the user gave at signup.
- Option CLoyalty card style
Give a few stamps on enrolment toward a longer goal, as in the car wash field study.
Timeline
- 12006 first documented: Nunes and Drèze (as covered by Knowledge at Wharton)
- 22006 Car wash loyalty card experiment — Card required 10 purchases with 2 awarded on enrolment vs a plain 8-purchase card.
- 32006 Car wash loyalty field study — 300 customers got cards; some started with two stamps already filled.
- 42026-11 status checked: Working
Dated examples
- 2006
Car wash loyalty card experiment
Card required 10 purchases with 2 awarded on enrolment vs a plain 8-purchase card.
Higher completion for the pre-stamped card (Wharton write-up).
“requires 10 purchases, but with two awarded upon enrollment”
○ page blocks automated checks; quote as relayedknowledge.wharton.upenn.edu · 2006-09-06
- 2006
Car wash loyalty field study
300 customers got cards; some started with two stamps already filled.
Head-start group completed more and sooner.
“This increases the likelihood of task completion and decreases completion time.”
○ page blocks automated checks; quote as relayedknowledge.wharton.upenn.edu · 2006-09-06
Does it still work?
Marketing study from 2006 (not an onboarding test); onboarding use is by analogy.
Risks
- Evidence is loyalty cards, not software onboarding
- Single field study in one setting
- Fake progress that feels arbitrary can backfire
Sources
- knowledge.wharton.upenn.edu
“This increases the likelihood of task completion and decreases completion time.”
○ page blocks automated checks; quote as relayed
Change log
- 2026-11-20 — merged: activation.jsonl:58 (endowed-progress-head-start); retention.jsonl:17 (endowed-progress-head-start)
- 2026-11-20 — harvest v0.1 (activation, retention)