Working · 2024-04AnecdotalRevenuePricing

Decoy tier (asymmetric dominance)

Add a plan that is slightly worse than the target plan at nearly the same price, so the target looks like better value.

Also called: asymmetric dominance, asymmetrical dominance effect, Decoy tier (asymmetric dominance)

Claim and evidence

The claimNow just 16% chose the cheaper option, with 84% opting for the obviously better combined option.

The Economist (Dan Ariely classroom test) · theconversation.com · 2019-02-17

What the numbers show

Students choosing the cheapest Economist offer (Dan Ariely classroom test, via The Conversation)

68%16%

Note: Classroom experiment, not live sales.

Why it works

Diagram, not data
BasicDecoy: almost thetarget, same priceTarget: clearly bettervalue
BasicDecoy:almostthetarget,samepriceTarget:clearlybettervalue

Buyers judge options relative to each other; a similar but inferior neighbour makes the preferred plan an easy pick.

How to run it

  1. Choose the plan you want most buyers on
  2. Add a lookalike with a clear gap
  3. Price it close to the target
  4. A/B test against the plain two-tier page
  5. Keep the decoy honest, not deceptive

Before / after

Before
Basic
Pro
Two plans side by side
After
Basic
Pro Lite
Pro
A near-twin makes the target obvious

Generalised wireframe of the pattern, not a copy of any company's screen.

Ways to run it

Design options to test, not promised results.

  1. Option ASame price, fewer features

    The decoy costs the same as the target but includes less.

  2. Option BSlightly cheaper, much less

    The decoy is a little cheaper than the target with a clear gap in value.

  3. Option COversized top tier

    An expensive plan above the target makes the target look moderate.

Dated examples

  1. —

    The Economist (Dan Ariely classroom test)

    Ariely showed 100 students the magazine's web-only, print-only and print-plus-web offers; the print-only option cost the same as the bundle and acted as the decoy.

    With the decoy present the cheap web-only option fell from 68% to 16% of choices and the bundle took 84% (student experiment, not live sales).

    “Now just 16% chose the cheaper option, with 84% opting for the obviously better combined option.”
    ✓ quote checked word-for-word on the page

    theconversation.com · 2019-02-17

Does it still work?

Workingas of 2024-04

Taught widely; the Simon-Kucher page gives a hypothetical example and no measured effect. source

Risks

  • Can read as manipulation if the decoy is plainly useless
  • Needs a test, not a belief, to confirm lift

Sources

  1. simon-kucher.com · Simon-Kucher · 2024-04-17
    “is a strategic pricing method that influences consumer choice towards a more expensive or profitable option.”
    ✓ quote checked word-for-word on the page
  2. theconversation.com · The Conversation · Gary Mortimer · 2019-02-17
    “In this second scenario the print-only option had become the decoy and the combined option the target.”
    ✓ quote checked word-for-word on the page

Change log

  • 2026-11-20 — merged: pass2-enrich.jsonl:3 (decoy-tier); revenue-expansion.jsonl:11 (decoy-tier)
  • 2026-11-20 — harvest v0.1 (pass2-enrich, revenue-expansion)