Claim and evidence
Now just 16% chose the cheaper option, with 84% opting for the obviously better combined option.The Economist (Dan Ariely classroom test) · theconversation.com · 2019-02-17
Anecdotal
Practitioner experience without published numbers.
With the decoy present the cheap web-only option fell from 68% to 16% of choices and the bundle took 84% (student experiment, not live sales).
Working · 2024-04 Taught widely; the Simon-Kucher page gives a hypothetical example and no measured effect.
What the numbers show
68%16%
Note: Classroom experiment, not live sales.
Why it works
Buyers judge options relative to each other; a similar but inferior neighbour makes the preferred plan an easy pick.
How to run it
- Choose the plan you want most buyers on
- Add a lookalike with a clear gap
- Price it close to the target
- A/B test against the plain two-tier page
- Keep the decoy honest, not deceptive
Before / after
Generalised wireframe of the pattern, not a copy of any company's screen.
Ways to run it
Design options to test, not promised results.
- Option ASame price, fewer features
The decoy costs the same as the target but includes less.
- Option BSlightly cheaper, much less
The decoy is a little cheaper than the target with a clear gap in value.
- Option COversized top tier
An expensive plan above the target makes the target look moderate.
Dated examples
- —
The Economist (Dan Ariely classroom test)
Ariely showed 100 students the magazine's web-only, print-only and print-plus-web offers; the print-only option cost the same as the bundle and acted as the decoy.
With the decoy present the cheap web-only option fell from 68% to 16% of choices and the bundle took 84% (student experiment, not live sales).
“Now just 16% chose the cheaper option, with 84% opting for the obviously better combined option.”
✓ quote checked word-for-word on the pagetheconversation.com · 2019-02-17
Does it still work?
Taught widely; the Simon-Kucher page gives a hypothetical example and no measured effect. source
Risks
- Can read as manipulation if the decoy is plainly useless
- Needs a test, not a belief, to confirm lift
Sources
- simon-kucher.com
“is a strategic pricing method that influences consumer choice towards a more expensive or profitable option.”
✓ quote checked word-for-word on the page - theconversation.com
“In this second scenario the print-only option had become the decoy and the combined option the target.”
✓ quote checked word-for-word on the page
Change log
- 2026-11-20 — merged: pass2-enrich.jsonl:3 (decoy-tier); revenue-expansion.jsonl:11 (decoy-tier)
- 2026-11-20 — harvest v0.1 (pass2-enrich, revenue-expansion)