Restricted · 2025-09SecondaryRetentionProcess

Design cancellation to meet auto-renewal law

Make cancel as easy as sign-up through the same channel, with a clear button; keep save offers to one optional step.

Also called: click-to-cancel compliance

Claim and evidence

The claimIn particular, Amazon is required to present customers with a clear button to cancel their Prime membership.

Amazon (FTC settlement) · goodwinlaw.com · 2025-09-29

What the numbers show

$2.5 billion

monetary judgment Amazon agreed to pay in its FTC settlement over Prime enrollment and cancellation

goodwinlaw.com
$1 billion

civil penalty to the FTC, included in that judgment

goodwinlaw.com

Why it works

Diagram, not data
Cancel in thesign-up channelClear cancelbuttonOne optionalsave offerCancelledwithin twoclicks
Cancel in the sign-up channelClear cancel buttonOne optional save offerCancelled within two clicks

Regulators penalize hard-to-cancel flows; compliant design protects against fines and chargebacks while preserving a limited save step.

How to run it

  1. Offer cancel through the same channel as enrollment
  2. Provide a clear cancel button
  3. Allow at most two clicks after declining an offer
  4. Check state auto-renewal laws
  5. Log consent and renewal notices

Before / after

Before
Manage membership
To cancel, please contact support
Keep my membership
Cancelling means finding support
After
Manage membership
Cancel membership
See a cheaper option
Access continues until the end of the billing period
A clear button and one optional offer

Generalised wireframe of the pattern, not a copy of any company's screen.

Ways to run it

Design options to test, not promised results.

  1. Option ASame-channel cancel

    Let users cancel online if they signed up online, without a call or chat.

  2. Option BOne optional offer

    Show at most one save offer and keep the cancel path short after it is declined.

  3. Option CConsent and notice log

    Record consent at sign-up and every renewal notice sent, checked against state auto-renewal laws.

Dated examples

  1. 2025

    Amazon (FTC settlement)

    Order requires a clear button to cancel Prime and cancellation through the enrollment channel.

    $2.5B monetary judgment including a $1B civil penalty.

    “In particular, Amazon is required to present customers with a clear button to cancel their Prime membership.”
    ✓ quote checked word-for-word on the page

    goodwinlaw.com · 2025-09-29

Does it still work?

Restrictedas of 2025-09

FTC click-to-cancel rule vacated July 8, 2025 on procedure; ROSCA, FTC Act and state laws remain. source

Risks

  • Law varies by state and may change
  • Not legal advice

Sources

  1. fenwick.com · Fenwick · Tyler G. Newby, Molly Melcher, Kimberly Culp, Caroline Simeon-Rose · 2025-07-10
    “obtain express affirmative consent from consumers and provide simple cancelation methods”
    ○ page blocks automated checks; quote as relayed
  2. goodwinlaw.com · Goodwin · W. Kyle Tayman, Viona J. Harris, Danielle Rosenblum · 2025-09-29
    “Amazon agreed to pay a $2.5 billion monetary judgment, which includes a $1 billion civil penalty to the FTC.”
    ✓ quote checked word-for-word on the page

Change log

  • 2026-11-20 — harvest v0.1 (retention)