Claim and evidence
Free trials that require a credit card see 30% free-to-paid conversion – more than 5x ones that don’t require one.Free trial products (ChartMogul / ProductLed) · chartmogul.com · 2026-03-18
Secondary
A reputable third party analysed it (Lenny's Newsletter, First Round Review, Reforge, an Ahrefs study).
20% of trial products require a card; they see 30% free-to-paid conversion.
Restricted · 2025-07 Works, but negative-option rules (US state auto-renewal laws, EU/UK subscription rules) now govern disclosure, consent and cancellation; see regulatory records.
What the numbers show
free-to-paid conversion for trials that require a card (ChartMogul / ProductLed survey, 2026)
chartmogul.commay drop off at the card screen, per Elena Verna (2025)
amplitude.comWhy it works
Card walls filter for intent and lift trial-to-paid rate, but cut the number who start. Net effect depends on which metric you count.
How to run it
- Decide whether volume or conversion rate matters more
- Test card-required vs no-card on end-to-end conversion
- Measure churn of conversions after 60 days
- Add trial-ending reminders
Before / after
Generalised wireframe of the pattern, not a copy of any company's screen.
Ways to run it
Design options to test, not promised results.
- Option ACard up front
Ask for a card before the trial starts, with clear renewal terms and an easy cancel.
- Option BNo card, then ask
Let anyone start; ask for a card only when they hit value or the trial ends.
- Option CReverse trial
Start everyone on paid features without a card, then drop them to a free plan instead of locking them out.
Timeline
- 12013 Sixteen Ventures (Lincoln Murphy) — Argues the opt-out trial does little for conversions.
- 22025 Amplitude (Elena Verna) — Describes the trade-off for card trials.
- 32025-07 status checked: Restricted
- 42026 Free trial products (ChartMogul / ProductLed) — Survey on card requirement.
- 52026 Survey of 200 B2B software products — Study run January 2026 with ChartMogul and ProductLed; card-required trials had the top conversion benchmark.
Dated examples
- 2026
Free trial products (ChartMogul / ProductLed)
Survey on card requirement.
20% of trial products require a card; they see 30% free-to-paid conversion.
“Free trials that require a credit card see 30% free-to-paid conversion – more than 5x ones that don’t require one.”
✓ quote checked word-for-word on the pagechartmogul.com · 2026-03-18
- 2026
Survey of 200 B2B software products
Study run January 2026 with ChartMogul and ProductLed; card-required trials had the top conversion benchmark.
Card-required trials converted far more often than no-card trials, before adjusting for signup rate.
“Free trials that require a credit card see 30% free-to-paid conversion – more than 5x ones that don't require one.”
✓ quote checked word-for-word on the pagegrowthunhinged.com · 2026-02-04
- 2025
Amplitude (Elena Verna)
Describes the trade-off for card trials.
70-80% of starters convert, but as many as 80% drop at the card screen.
“as many as 80% of people will drop off at the credit card screen.”
✓ quote checked word-for-word on the pageamplitude.com · 2025-06-03
- 2013
Sixteen Ventures (Lincoln Murphy)
Argues the opt-out trial does little for conversions.
Guarantees only fewer prospects.
“The only thing I can guarantee with an Opt-Out SaaS Free Trial is that you’ll get less prospective customers”
✓ quote checked word-for-word on the pagesixteenventures.com · 2013-04-25
Does it still work?
Works, but negative-option rules (US state auto-renewal laws, EU/UK subscription rules) now govern disclosure, consent and cancellation; see regulatory records. source
Risks
- Higher accidental-conversion churn
- Conversion rate vs volume trade-off: compare end to end
- Fewer trial starts; the report says the gap to no-card trials narrows once signup rate is accounted for
- Surprise-charge refunds and chargebacks
- Negative-option law exposure
Sources
- chartmogul.com
“Free trials that require a credit card see 30% free-to-paid conversion – more than 5x ones that don’t require one.”
✓ quote checked word-for-word on the page - amplitude.com
“as many as 80% of people will drop off at the credit card screen.”
✓ quote checked word-for-word on the page - sixteenventures.com
“The only thing I can guarantee with an Opt-Out SaaS Free Trial is that you’ll get less prospective customers”
✓ quote checked word-for-word on the page - growthunhinged.com
“Free trials that require a credit card see 30% free-to-paid conversion – more than 5x ones that don't require one.”
✓ quote checked word-for-word on the page
Change log
- 2026-11-20 — merged: activation.jsonl:60 (card-required-opt-out-trial); revenue-expansion.jsonl:2 (card-required-trial)
- 2026-11-20 — harvest v0.1 (activation, revenue-expansion)