Claim and evidence
Most people just removed the broken link instead of replacing it.Overloop · overloop.com · 2026-05-04
Secondary
A reputable third party analysed it (Lenny's Newsletter, First Round Review, Reforge, an Ahrefs study).
3.2% replied and 0.8% gave a link; the resource-mention angle did about twice as well.
Working · 2022-05 Ahrefs 2022 says results are mixed and execution-dependent; it ranks fifth in a 250-practitioner survey
What the numbers show
No published number for this tactic has passed our word-for-word check yet, so there is no chart.
Why it works
Webmasters want working links, so a replacement that fits is an easy fix; deep links with a clear reason are easiest to win.
How to run it
- Find dead pages with backlinks
- Vet prospects and why they linked
- Build a replacement guided by the Wayback Machine copy
- Send grouped outreach templates by link reason
Ways to run it
Design options to test, not promised results.
- Option AWayback-guided rebuild
Use the archived copy of the dead page to build a replacement that covers what linkers relied on.
- Option BGrouped outreach by reason
Group prospects by why they linked and write one template per group.
- Option CMixed angles
Test the broken-link pitch next to a resource-mention pitch, as Overloop did, since many sites just remove the dead link.
Timeline
- 12022-05 status checked: Working
- 22026 Overloop — Tested a broken-link angle with 100 contacts inside a cold-email link-building campaign, next to a 'resource mention' angle.
Dated examples
- 2026
Overloop
Tested a broken-link angle with 100 contacts inside a cold-email link-building campaign, next to a 'resource mention' angle.
3.2% replied and 0.8% gave a link; the resource-mention angle did about twice as well.
“Most people just removed the broken link instead of replacing it.”
✓ quote checked word-for-word on the pageoverloop.com · 2026-05-04
Does it still work?
Ahrefs 2022 says results are mixed and execution-dependent; it ranks fifth in a 250-practitioner survey source
Risks
- No success rates published
- Needs paid tools
- Labour-intensive
Sources
- ahrefs.com
“Broken link building isn't easy. Sometimes, it works well. Sometimes, it doesn't.”
✓ quote checked word-for-word on the page - searchenginejournal.com
“publishers and website owners are starting to get fatigued by all the various outreach requests.”
✓ quote checked word-for-word on the page
Change log
- 2026-11-20 — merged: pass2-enrich.jsonl:19 (broken-link-building); acq-search.jsonl:13 (broken-link-building)
- 2026-11-20 — harvest v0.1 (pass2-enrich, acq-search)